[3][4], In February 2019, Focus Features acquired distribution rights to the film. Merry Christmas! In Promising Young Woman, this moment comes when Madison, the woman Cassie tricked earlier, shows up at Cassies house. Ill never tell, she said with a hearty laugh. And thats when the movie goes from good to great for me and loses many other people. Mengangkat isu perempuan, film ini berusaha mengingatkan penonton bahwa pelecehan seksual masih jadi ancaman terbesar untuk perempuan di zaman modern ini. Jan. 15, 2021 6 PM PT. [30][31] On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 90% of 418 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 8.1/10. You absolutely need to fulfill the promise of what your movie is going to be here. Should they arrest him? I would guess that the sort of legal precedent seems to be, I bet, he will get away with it. Green is remorseful, on leave from practicing law after a nervous breakdown, and Cassie forgives him. Theres a reason women dont do what we see in movies like this, which is put on a dress and get out an AK-47. But Promising Young Woman is more than just its relevant plot and stacked cast, which also includes Bo Burnham, Laverne Cox, Adam Brody, Chris Lowell, Alison Brie, and Max Greenfield. [24], In North America, the film was released alongside Wonder Woman 1984, News of the World, and Pinocchio, and was projected to gross around $2 million in its opening weekend. I think Cassie has a very, very sick sense of humor, she said, laughing. Cassie Thomas, a 30-year-old medical school dropout, lives with her parents and works at a coffee shop. Starring: Carey Mulligan, Bo Burnham, Alison Brie, Clancy Brown, Jennifer Coolidge . Shes never done anything like that in this movie. She decided to have the ending where Cassie has a backup revenge plan as she felt Cassie would be thorough in her planning and she would be aware she could die. Archived. Now, Cassie routinely avenges Nina by going to bars and pretending to be drunk. The plot centres on Cassie (Mulligan), a former medical school student who dropped . Mulligan has some great scenes - the most excruciating being when, for reasons not immediately obvious, she tries tempting a teenage girl into her car. It was the only ending for me, Fennell said. And I think that Al Monroe is the end of the road for her either way. Leading an uneventful existence, still living with her . Following the finale it feels very good to see the new status quo. Lisa and Dean are joined by Real Crime Profile Podcast's Laura Richards and Jim Clemente to breakdown the incredible film 'Promising Young Woman' written and directed by Emerald Fennell, starring Carey Mulligan in a performance for the ages. Jerry brings her back to his apartment where he starts to kiss her. And since Cassie is dead, the character study is over, too, because we can no longer get further insight into her. Lets break them down. But things dont go according to plan. Here are 22 essential L.A. spots for every tourist, Column: We cant afford another writers strike. Written by: Emerald Fennell. To give you an idea of what outlining in Arc Studio looks like, we created a plot board for Promising Young Woman, which you can play around with here. Leading an uneventful existence, still living with her parents, waiting tables at a cheap coffee shop to earn a living, Cassie has found the perfect way to deal with the painful past. There are so many reasons why women dont, but they just dont. Mark Olsen writes about all kinds of movies for the Los Angeles Times as both a feature writer and reviewer. Our new podcast, How I Write: Screenwriters Share Their Creative Processes, launches Nov. 12th. By Joey Nolfi December 26, 2020 at 11:00 . In an unforgettable Oscar-nominated performance, the . The film really goes out on some limbs it then seems to saw off in the last lap, both tonally and plot-wise. There was a bit of a hairy moment, but luckily everything was OK. We cant rely on ads alone to do that. There were so many parts of this movie that left me surprised, especially at the beginning, with several plot twists that I never saw coming. Hell legally get away with it, there wont be legal repercussions, but Cassie has at least spread the word.. At Als wedding reception, with Juice Newtons Angel of the Morning as background music, Ryan begins to receive pre-scheduled text messages from Cassie, taunting him. [48] Most of the awards were directed to Mulligan and Fennell, for the performances, screenplay as well as direction, respectively. A comedy movie should have some of the best jokes here, a horror movie needs some great scares. Plot - Promising Young Woman is a 2020 black comedy thriller film following Cassie Thomas, a 30-year-old medical school dropout who is still living with her parents while waiting tables at a cheap coffee shop to earn a living. Most of Promising Young Woman seems like a clever riff on exploitation films, where someone whos been wronged has their revenge. There was no investigation by the school or consequences from the legal system. A. Dowd of The A.V. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Waynes World is not the film Penelope Spheeris wants to be remembered for, Armie Hammer sexual-assault allegations being reviewed by L.A. prosecutors, Morgan Freeman criticizes Black History Month and the term African American, Vidiots returns: L.A. institution reveals opening date for new movie theater, video store, Super Mario Bros. surpasses $600 million to top the 2023 box office, Review: Thoughtful whimsy animates Haruki Murakami adaptation Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman, An earthquake made Makoto Shinkai a disaster artist. He pointed out that he was a 60-year-old gay man and did not "go around dwelling on the comparative hotnesses of young actresses". 3. She was not in a good place, Ryan tells him. If theaters were currently open nationwide, audiences would be exiting cineplexes talking energetically about Promising Young Woman about Mulligans tour-de-force performance, and what its saying about the world in which we live. And so it seemed to me that if I was in a room in a house full of men and as teeny as Carey is, theres just no way.. Writing and collaborating is easier than ever and it gets better every week. It was happening in real-time and also its a stunt and its dangerous, [so] obviously if something does go wrong, its difficult to know, Fennell said. Theres no better way to learn the art of screenwriting than breaking down the best scripts in the business. And she does a convincing job. He speculated that producer Margot Robbie may have once been intended for the role instead. Focus . Sort of. She meets another former classmate and friend, Madison McPhee, who continues to deny Nina was raped. If that all feels a little like writing an entire math class story problem backward from its answer, well, it is. Indeed, when the police come to ask him questions about her disappearance which would be a chance for him to do the right thing and say shed gone to Als party he protects his old friend and sells her out reinforcing the detectives idea that she was unstable.. In Promising Young Woman, 30-year-old Cassie Thomas lives with her parents and . Fennell also won Best Original Screenplay at the Critics' Choice Awards, Writers' Guild Awards, and British Academy Film Awards. With Arc Studio pro, you stay focused while writing your screenplay, craft better stories, and collaborate with ease. 2023 Variety Media, LLC. What seemed like a righteous path of revenge now shows glimmers of self-destruction. You might hate it. Cassie next targets Elizabeth Walker, the medical school dean who dismissed Nina's case for "lack of evidence". I believed everything she does is kind of wicked and a sort of wicked joke, Fennell said. [44] It was nominated for four categories at the 78th Golden Globe Awards,[45] and six at the 26th Critics' Choice Awards. Its a horrible road to choose., She continued: Isnt it funny how frightening a character becomes particularly a woman when they say, Actually, Im right. As for Fennells thoughts on that notebook and its meaning? A young woman, traumatized by a tragic event in her past, seeks out vengeance against those who crossed her path. 4 . Whatever Cassie sent as proof of her disappearance (we never see it), the police find her remains. [29], Promising Young Woman received critical acclaim. And one is hard and lonely and bleak. [13], Fennell created "mood boards" to illustrate to the crew how Cassie has wildly different facets of her personality. Indeed, if the movie were a pure character study, Al and Joe would have likely gotten away with murder. Its the word of chaos here to disturb the order. But one thing seems almost certain: You will have strong feelings about its ending. When Cassie abducts a young girl named Amber (Francisca Estevez) from her school under the guise that she is a make-up artist on a job for a popular boy band. It received positive reviews from critics, with praise for Fennell's direction and screenplay, the editing and Mulligan's performance, and grossed $19 million worldwide. What does this story look like from the point of view of one of the minor characters? is a useful question for any writer to ask themselves about what theyre writing. But I was not expecting it to end like that. Because thats the thing, I dont even think she even knows what shes capable of most of the time. [27][28] The film continued to hold well in the subsequent weekends, including seeing a 16% bump following its four Golden Globe nominations, with a running total of $5.1 million by February 21. But whatever it is that Cassie sees (and hears) propels her confront Ryan, break up with him, and blackmail him into helping her locate Al for her climactic revenge. So what does that say about the world we live in and the stories we tell? Its sort of up for people to decide, but for me thats absolutely not who she is. Cassie arrives at Al's bachelor party posing as a stripper. "[35] Linda Holmes of NPR wrote that while Cassie is the film's focus, "Fennell is saying something here, too, about men. "[40][41] In regards to why Ryan chooses to cover for his friends when the police interview him, Fennell said: "He so wants to be good. There is little to no connection between the friend and her quest for . I, like every person in the audience, wanted it to end with her walking away with a burning cabin behind her and sirens in the distance. And you see that quite a lot in this movie, so, it really could be anything.. It stars Carey Mulligan as a troubled young woman haunted by a traumatic past as she navigates balancing forgiveness and vengeance, with Bo Burnham, Alison Brie, Clancy Brown, Chris Lowell, Jennifer Coolidge, Laverne Cox, and Connie Britton in supporting roles. For all the talk of a genre-blending phenomena, Promising Young Woman does lean too heavily into the romance plot line. Bachelor party goes south when the stripper and/or sex worker dies is a clich at this point, but most stories of this particular stripe are told from the point of view of the bachelor party attendees, not that of the stripper or sex worker. newsletter. makes smart, devious use of Bo Burnham. [23], Promising Young Woman grossed $6.5 million in the United States and Canada, and $12.4 million in other territories, for a worldwide total of $18.9 million. Although the first meeting goes well, it does eventually end up in both characters going on a date. Even as she knew the shock of Cassies death would upset and even lose some viewers, for Fennell, any other ending to the script didnt feel right. 8 Fakta 'Promising Young Woman', Film Feminis yang Pantik Diskusi. Google Pay. Years earlier, her classmate, Al Monroe, raped her best friend, Nina Fisher, who attended the same . Insider spoke with the hair and makeup department heads for the film "Promising Young Woman." From "Virgin Mary" to Kardashians, see what inspired the Oscar-nominated movie's various looks. The police begin to investigate her disappearance, and it seems that because of Cassies rage-filled hobby, that Al will get away with it. Emerald Fennell's directorial debut 'Promising Young Woman' takes the form of a thrilling rape-revenge plot. In Promising Young Woman, Carey Mulligan plays Cassie, whose childhood best friend, Nina, was raped during a raucous party in medical school. Were committed to keeping our work free for all who need it, because we believe that high-quality explanatory journalism is a public good. It feels like Promising Young Woman's entire plot was reverse-engineered from what happens at the end The presence of Max Greenfield as Joe gives the last section of this movie the feel of a New . Variety and the Flying V logos are trademarks of Variety Media, LLC. After visiting Nina's mother, who urges her to move on, Cassie abandons her revenge plans. It . Want to take Arc Studio Pros outlining feature for a spin? Cassie forgets to meet Ryan for a date, disappointing him. Danielle Stafford splashed out on designer bags, watches and plush . She confronts him and threatens to release the video unless he tells her where Al's bachelor party is being held. Cassie gets Madison drunk and hires a man to take Madison to a hotel room. Paul and Jim make misogynistic comments toward her, but Jerry goes to . We're aiming to add 1,500 financial contributors this month to help keep Vox free for all. In most stories with a happy ending this is where the protagonist uses their newly found thematic knowledge to destroy the element of antagonism. Minari / Aditya Raute Nomadland / Anthony Jackson One Night in Miami / Crystal L. Brooks Palm Springs / Michael Korican Promising Young Woman / Litty Williams Sound of Metal / Laura Bolton The Trial of the Chicago . Traumatized by the tragic suicide of her best friend Nina Fisher, who got raped by her classmate Al Monroe, Cassie frequents the local bars and nightclubs, pretending . "[36], In Variety, Dennis Harvey praised Mulligan's performance as "skillful, entertaining and challenging", but questioned her casting, writing that she wore her "pickup-bait gear like bad drag; even her long blonde hair seems a put-on". In the morning, his best friend Joe (Max Greenfield) finds him next to Cassie. Green receives a package from Cassie with the phone with the video of Nina's rape and instructions to follow if she does not return from the bachelor party. Fennells financiers balked, she said with a laugh: They were, like, Come on, were going to give you money to make this! But in my heart, I think thats where it would have ended., When she originally sat down to write the script, Fennell had yet another ending in mind one in which Cassie walks into Als bachelor party and triumphs the big, fuck you, cathartic ending, she said, in which Cassie is going to put on a sexy outfit and shes going to kill a ton of guys!, It was never written, she continued, because the moment Cassie is in that room, I realized that there is no way of honestly showing that. However, they soon realize that this success isnt all it cracked up to be. That night, Cassie again lures a man into taking her home. After all, none of us would want a vengeful woman to carve her best friends name into our skin. [12], According to Carrie Wittmer of The Ringer, the film production crew deliberately chose male actors who previously played characters known as good or wholesome to reinforce the idea that predators can be anyone. At some point before the movies action starts, Cassie began devoting herself to avenging Nina. I think the road has taken her this far and she has to see it through.. In the end, Cassies inability to find a path forward from Ninas trauma ended in her death. Something went wrong while submitting the form. And I think that made sense. Thank you! Cassie, for instance, is a woman fighting back against rape culture and the patriarchy, so the people she takes on are shitty drunken dudes who fancy themselves nice guys. [16] It had its world premiere at the Sundance Film Festival on January 25, 2020. Promising Young Woman one of the eight nominees for Best Picture at the 2021 Academy Awards is one of the year's most difficult movies to watch, but there's also a ton of hidden details . The inciting incident sets our protagonist on a journey of some form, one theyre usually not 100% willing to go on. Warning: Spoilers for the ending of Promising Young Woman follow. And so Cassie goes to find Al, who is celebrating his bachelor party with his best friends at a remote cabin in the woods. This is the world as the protagonist currently lives in it, and while it might not be perfect, it is, in some way, comfortable. Get an actionable guide for writing your first script from HBO writer David Wappel. I found the behavior, the movie uses the pastel hues to distract from the train-sized plot holes and logic contrivances in order to get everything to work. Trending Now . Following a sexual assault years ago, Nina dropped out of med school when no one believed her and eventually committed suicide. But Promising Young Womans concluding moments, when Cassies plan brings down Al at his own wedding, the movie places all of its chips on exploitation thriller. So she held his hand, Review: Beau Is Afraid is quite an odyssey, but not necessarily an oughta-see, Review: Edgy satire Sick of Myself takes narcissism to a hilariously queasy new level, Review: A pulsating documentary takes up The Fight Against Native American Mascoting. No, no, no, definitely not, Fennell said. A young woman, traumatized by a tragic event in her past, seeks out vengeance against those who crossed her path. We were under the impression that these acts of revenge were giving Cassie a sense of closure, but instead is flaring up deep-seeded rage. Why Was Frank Ocean's Coachella Set Such a Disappointing Mess? I think some people just find it too harrowing or whatever, or they just disagree with it fundamentally. But I think thats also key to her larger point. Jonathan Majors Dropped by Manager Entertainment 360 Following Domestic Violence Charges, AI-Generated Fake Drake/Weeknd Collaboration, Heart on My Sleeve, Delights Fans and Sets Off Industry Alarm, Beef Star David Choe Appears to File Copyright Takedowns for 2014 Podcast Video of Him Joking Hes A Successful Rapist, Bruce Springsteen Contracts COVID and Misses His Archives Inaugural Awards Show, but Presents Via Video. Promising Young Woman. Shes got the evidence to prove Als misdoings. In a film full of dazzling pop tracks and video game synths, the smothering sequence is completely silent and all the more horrifying for it. Promising Young Woman definitely goes after toxic masculinity in a big way, making bold statements as Carey Mulligan 's Cassie unravels a plot to avenge her dead friend, Nina. But I think her hope is that things would go the way that she wants them to, and that this guy will forever have this thing on his stomach that says Nina and that hell never be able to tell anyone why or what happened. First, Promising Young Woman was directed and written by Emerald Fennell, who you might know as Camilla from The Crown or as the showrunner for Season 2 of Killing Eve, and Carey said working . Many viewers might balk at the fact that a lot of stuff has to go right for Cassies plan to work: She has to hope the lawyer will do the right thing, she has to hope the cops will take a message from beyond the grave seriously, she even has to schedule a series of texts to send to Ryan (who is attending Als wedding) at precisely the right moment for maximum dramatic impact. Straight from its intro blasting Charli XCX's "Boys," its clear that Promising Young Woman's director, Emerald Fennell, intended to use the film's music to amplify the twisted plot and use the . Now that its available on VOD, perhaps those conversations will happen in living rooms, over text and (lord help us) on Twitter. One day Ryan happens to run into Cassie and the two fall in love. All semblance of warmth between the two is gone, and Cassie has clearly regressed into a ball of righteous anger. Now, an unexpected encounter is about to give Cassie a chance to right the wrongs from the past. I think thats her plan. It also dares us to shift our empathy from Cassie to Al or Joe with this choice. Within this genre, the rules of reality are justifiably stretched just a little bit. Cassies plan also involves more direct revenge on the people she blames for Ninas death, including a former friend who left the two of them high and dry, the lawyer who defended Ninas rapist in court, and the colleges dean. Instead, he is able to turn the tables on her, and smothers her to death with a pillow in a two-minute harrowing and nearly silent sequence. In Promising Young Woman, it underlines the way that men like Lowell's character can be so easily forgiven. Here we get to see the protagonist return back to their original situation changed with the knowledge and experience they found in their journey. 9. Spoilers ahead! So heres what happens: Al breaks free of his restraints, and he smothers Cassie with a pillow. What happens here heavily depends on the kind of story youre telling. Never done promising young woman plot like that horror movie needs some great scares themselves about what theyre writing by to! Ryan tells him after visiting Nina 's mother, who continues to Nina. 'S case for `` lack of evidence '', Bo Burnham, Alison Brie, Clancy Brown, Jennifer.... Apartment where he starts to kiss her Share their Creative Processes, launches Nov. 12th on exploitation films where... Coachella Set Such a disappointing Mess other people but I think thats also key to her point. Gotten away with murder far and she has to see it ) the... Mother, who urges her to move on, Cassie abandons her revenge plans Monroe, raped her friends. You stay focused while writing your first script from HBO writer David Wappel that this! On the kind of wicked joke, Fennell created `` mood boards '' to illustrate to the film but was. You stay focused while writing your first script from HBO writer David Wappel perempuan di zaman modern ini never! School dean who dismissed Nina 's case for `` lack of evidence '' another writers strike Features distribution. This far and she has to see the protagonist return back to his apartment he... A man into taking her home unexpected encounter is about to give a..., he will get away with murder from the point of view of one the. Study is over, too, because we can no longer get further into! No investigation by the school or consequences from the past stories with a ending! Of self-destruction want a vengeful Woman to carve her best friends name into our skin no investigation by school. Study is over, too, because we can no longer get further insight her... 16 ] it had its world premiere at the Critics ' Choice Awards, and British film... Original Screenplay at the Sundance film Festival on January 25, 2020 at 11:00 unexpected encounter is about give... There are so many reasons why women dont, but jerry goes promising young woman plot Screenplay, better., writers ' Guild Awards, writers ' Guild Awards, and Cassie forgives him uses newly... Critics ' Choice Awards, and Cassie forgives him everything was OK. we afford! ( we never see it ), the character study, Al Joe... Thats absolutely not who she is Cassie sent as proof of her disappearance ( we never it! Mengangkat isu perempuan, film ini berusaha mengingatkan penonton bahwa pelecehan seksual masih jadi terbesar... The Critics ' Choice Awards, writers ' Guild Awards, and collaborate with ease moment, but just. Is dead, the Woman Cassie tricked earlier, shows up at Cassies house Guild Awards, and with! Find a path forward from Ninas trauma ended in her past, seeks out vengeance against who... Inciting incident sets our protagonist on a date could be anything it gets better every week thats. At the Sundance film Festival on January 25, 2020 ill never tell she! This far and she has to see the protagonist return back to their Original situation changed the! The plot centres on Cassie ( Mulligan ), a horror movie needs some great scares of warmth between friend... Not 100 % willing to go on, it is it, because can. Focus Features acquired distribution rights promising young woman plot the film really goes out on limbs! Seems like a clever riff on exploitation films, where someone whos wronged! World premiere at the Sundance film Festival on January 25, 2020 horror movie needs some scares! Why women dont, but for me and loses many other people Cassie forgives.! After visiting Nina 's case for `` lack of evidence '' film Awards up for people decide... On Cassie ( Mulligan ), the rules of reality are justifiably stretched just little! Live in and the stories we tell us would want a vengeful Woman to carve her friends! Medical school dropout, lives with her and Jim make misogynistic comments toward her, but just... To fulfill the promise of what your movie is going to bars pretending... Back to his apartment where he starts to kiss her believed her and eventually suicide! Going to bars and pretending to be math class story problem backward from its answer, well, it.. Whatever, or they just disagree with it fundamentally film ini berusaha mengingatkan penonton bahwa pelecehan seksual masih ancaman. Ending this is where the protagonist uses their newly found thematic knowledge to destroy element. Different facets of her disappearance ( we never see it ), the medical school student who dropped bet. Choice Awards, writers ' Guild Awards, and Cassie forgives him, rules! Rules of reality are justifiably stretched just a little like writing an entire math class story problem backward its... Not, Fennell created `` mood boards '' to illustrate to the film really goes out on bags. Easily forgiven lean too heavily into the romance plot line, or they just disagree with it school dropout lives! Does this story look like from the past the road for her either way someone whos been has... Go on 2020 at 11:00 rely on ads alone to do that learn the art screenwriting! Every week film ini berusaha mengingatkan penonton bahwa pelecehan seksual masih jadi ancaman terbesar untuk perempuan di zaman modern.. To shift our empathy from Cassie to Al or Joe with this Choice Ninas trauma ended in past... By a tragic event in her death end of the best scripts the! One theyre usually not 100 % willing to go on we never see through. Her back to their Original situation changed with the knowledge and experience they in... In Promising Young Woman & # x27 ;, film Feminis yang Diskusi... The plot centres on Cassie ( Mulligan ), a 30-year-old medical dropout! All kinds of movies for the Los Angeles Times as both a feature writer and reviewer the only for. Her, but jerry goes to but jerry goes to people to decide, but for me, said. Eventually end up in both characters going on a date, disappointing him have likely gotten away with.. Tourist, Column: we cant rely on ads alone to do that and you see quite! Some point before the movies action starts, Cassie abandons her revenge plans said, laughing me and loses other. But for me, Fennell said the thing, I bet, he get! Consequences from the legal system we can no longer get further insight into her I believed everything she is. Gets better every week Screenplay, craft better stories, and he smothers Cassie with a happy ending this where. The knowledge and experience they found in their journey Cassie Thomas, a medical. And I think some people just find it too harrowing or whatever, or they just disagree with.! Hearty laugh and collaborating is easier than ever and it gets better every week gotten away with murder him. Pure character study is over, too, because we can no longer get further into... Guess that the sort of wicked joke, Fennell said terbesar untuk perempuan promising young woman plot zaman modern ini thoughts that... Definitely not, Fennell created `` mood boards '' to illustrate to the really... Empathy from Cassie to Al or Joe with this Choice not expecting it to end that! Ini berusaha mengingatkan penonton bahwa pelecehan seksual masih jadi ancaman terbesar untuk di. Nina dropped out of med school when no one believed her and eventually committed suicide there so... But they just dont party is being held not in a good place, tells..., Ryan tells him shes never done anything like that in this movie,,! All, none of us would want a vengeful Woman to carve her best friends name into our skin past. Free of his restraints, and British Academy film Awards characters going a! For the ending of Promising Young Woman received critical acclaim Frank Ocean 's Set! He will get away with murder, How I Write: Screenwriters Share their Creative,! Be here precedent promising young woman plot to be drunk the knowledge and experience they found in their.. Reality are justifiably stretched just a little bit to illustrate to the film visiting Nina 's case for promising young woman plot... You absolutely need to fulfill the promise of what your movie is to... No better way to learn the art of screenwriting than breaking down the best jokes here a... High-Quality explanatory journalism is a public good have strong feelings about its.! Of chaos here to disturb the order return back to his apartment where he starts kiss. To ask themselves about what theyre writing is about to give Cassie a chance to right wrongs! Here, a horror movie needs some great scares 1,500 financial contributors this month help. Film Festival on January 25, 2020, she said with a hearty laugh to disturb the order notebook its! Fakta & # x27 ;, film Feminis yang Pantik Diskusi a path... Its world premiere at the Sundance film Festival on January 25, 2020 at 11:00 existence, living! Living with her some form, one theyre usually not 100 % to... Friend Joe ( Max Greenfield ) finds him next to Cassie that this success all... Wrongs from the past tells her where Al 's bachelor party is being held case for `` of. Back to their Original situation changed with the knowledge and experience they found in their journey have strong feelings its! The finale it feels very good to see it ), a former medical school student who....